11-plus update

Besides a lot of homeless related stuff in which I declare an interest, I couldn’t help noticing an article, along with editorial, in today’s Echo, noting 11+ success rates among Southend’s primary schools have risen. This in the light efforts by the Council to improve success rates and (according to the Echo) following its campaign that pointed out the fact that the number of children from the town’s primary schools going to the town’s grammar schools, had fallen from 296 in 2004 to 197 in 2013 with some primary schools doing well and others not sending a single pupil to the grammar schools.

Credit where credit is due and today’s news is to be welcome, although I would like to point out when I published my “A Parent’s guide to the 11-plus” six years ago and, when I tried to interest the council and schools, I was treated with a certain disdain and was largely ignored by the Echo. I decided I need to focus my efforts on more fruitful avenues of service, according to the Reinhold Niebuhr (of serenity prayer fame) principle. Yet the reasons for my involvement remain clear and justifiable. This was (is) for me a social justice issue, and also an education one. I had a bright child wanting to go to a grammar school that attended an otherwise good primary school that gave the impression the 11-plus didn’t exist and made it quite clear they weren’t going to do anything extra to change what they did and certainly not by way of providing the help needed for children to be able to pass the 11+, noting that SATS (what schools work towards) and the 11-plus are very different exams.

My afore-mentioned child is about to go into the Upper Sixth at one of the town’s grammar schools and I don’t regret for a moment being his tutor to help him prepare for and pass the 11-plus and for writing the book, which I know has helped other parents who were in a similar position to us. For me, the main issues were (and still are) standards, discipline and manners and, while it would be unfair and simplistic to say a child gets these if they go to a grammar school and won’t get them if they don’t, I have to say it was with some relief to find that he had passed. Not that everything is as rosy as it seems when it comes to grammar schools: the overwhelming preoccupation with passing exams and what appears to be more affirmation given to those who go along with what the school offers than those who don’t, are two matters I might take issue with.

Since I wrote my book, I have blogged on a number of occasions, on education matters, and one of the reoccurring themes concerns what is education and how best can it be delivered? Regarding grammar schools, while I will continue to be supportive, long after my young charge has left, I remain ambivalent as to whether I can whole heartedly support the principle of selective education. Given that I have yet to find compelling evidence that comprehensives deliver in all the necessary areas when it comes to the brighter child, I am inclined to support the status quo, while ensuring a level playing field at the same time, at least until the revolution that I have been wanting comes about. I am concerned we still have schools in the town that have been labeled as failing by Ofsted and that is where many “disadvantaged” children end up. An even bigger challenge is ensuring children who go to these by default get a good education.


One thought on “11-plus update

  1. My eldest is about to start grammar. We supported him to pass. He had the intelligence to pass, proven by his level 5as bs and 6s for his SATS, but had no idea about how to sit an exam.

    His primary said they would set up 11+ support sessions this was in February. They didn’t materialise until after may half term. By then much too late to really help. Work he was given wasn’t marked we never received feedback directly on what he needed further help with etc.

    I understand the schools not wanting to push the 11+ but if you have parents who are going to have their children sit surely support them as best they can!

    I have 2 further children who will sit the 11+ all my past experience has taught me is if I want them to pass we as a family have to make that commitment and anything the school gives is a bonus.

    We have also moved house so should any not pass we are in an alternative catchment as my limited experience of the previous catchment wasn’t encouraging. My son on a school visit said he was appalled by students behaviour. I believe that this is the bigger local problem not the grammars. I’ve heard the argument about taking the top children out of local comps etc. It just doesn’t wash with me and feel like it’s an excuse. I went to an inner London comp which had a larger than average E.A.L. population and a number of children with behavioural issues which managed to overcome barriers to education to achieve better standards in the 90s than the local comps are now. That’s just not acceptable. This should be the focus not attacking the grammar system.

    Every Child should have the same chances I personally think while we have selective education parents should have the option for schools to register the children and spend more time educating parents that it doesn’t cost anything to enter the 11+ I was suprised at the parents who thought you had to pay to enter.

    At the end of the day it’s totally out of our hands as parents what happens on the day but at least we know we have given our children the best locally available option.

Have your say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s